The Price of a Wish - Chapter 1
The Price of a Wish - Chapter 1
Another day. Another night. Another absolute disaster.
In other words...same problems, different day. And this last year? Worst. Damn. Year.
Probably shouldn’t be checking my phone so much. It wasn't going to change anything. Analyzing every message, every missed call, every possible interpretation wasn't going to magically produce the outcome I wanted. As if ignoring my thoughts would, or could, somehow change everything I wished could be different.
Across the room, Emily and Eric were doing their best to keep the evening alive, mingling with their newly made friends. They wanted the same for me tonight. I appreciated the effort. I always do… truly.
Sadly, being surrounded by people never has been particularly effective at making me feel less alone. There's something strange about being surrounded by people and feeling so utterly alone.
The strangest part? I don't care.
I take another sip of my drink.
"Careful, darling. With a lovely face like that, someone might take you seriously. Such a shame."
I turn to the source.
A well-dressed man had settled in the empty seat beside me. Sort of handsome, actually.
I scan him up and down. I can tell his type, one-hundred percent. He’s a man who's probably never had to wonder whether he belongs in a room. Not my favorite.
I turn back to face the direction of my friends.
Not interested.
He watches me dismiss him.
The silence stretches, thankfully. I take another sip. Maybe he could be willed away. Maybe I could even pray to a god who’d have personal interest in preserving my public solitude.
Interesting.
He'd expected curiosity, perhaps suspicion. Maybe even a little recognition. Instead, he'd received the equivalent of being dismissed by an unimpressed cat.
He wasn't accustomed to being ignored. Usually, he found such encounters tedious, and found these exchanges to be lacking in entertainment. This one, however…this one was different.
I ignore an arrogant, attention-seeking cough behind me. Enjoying my well earned peace, the woman sitting directly in front of me setting her tab, closes her clutch purse, and leaves. A moment later, the same man saunters into my line of sight and takes her seat as if it was his turn to step onto the stage. My brow furrows as our eyes meet. I take another sip of my drink.
He’s breathtaking, I'll give him that. Dressed with effortless confidence, he wears a smile that suggests he knows an old secret the rest of the world has somehow missed; perhaps a secret he wanted to share with me.
He glances at me, then at my drink.
"That expression and attitude tell me you haven't had the best day. Let me guess... feeling stuck? Career not where you want it to be? Love life is not quite what you imagined, or perhaps even..."
“Fuck off…”
"What?" His expression more than hints I've just managed to slam the emergency brakes on his extravagant presentation. Still, he recovers. "Are you always this friendly?"
“I said fuck off,” Jesus can’t he take a hint.
Lucifer smiles. Oh, this is going to be fun.
"Well, I see today, this week, this month, this year, perhaps even this decade...might not have been what you hoped for. If I were to guess, of course."
He tilts his head.
"How unfortunate. Considering I'm rather good at fixing such….non-ideal situations."
I take another sip. Fantastic. Add ignoring handsome strangers to the list of hobbies I didn’t care to know.
“Nice to meet you.” I light up my face with a soft smile, and welcoming voice. For a moment, he looks surprised, then smirks and opens his mouth.
"Good luck..." I sing before he can get a word out. I stand, the chair scrapes against the floor as I make for my exit. Time for some fresh air. In fact, the patio sounds wonderful…it’ll be quieter. But the best part is it’s free of…
“As I was saying, darling.” His voice comes from right beside me. A dangerous purr follows his presence, as his shoulder brushes mine.
I jump away from the contact.
“Jesus! Where did you come from? You know what…never mind…” I huff “God, you reek of desperation.”
"Me? Desperate?" The purr disappears, replaced with confused shock.
Yep…struck a nerve.
“Whatever you’re selling you got others to peddle your wares. Mr. A-person-I-don't-care-about.”
"Oh, darling, I would if they had anything I actually wanted. But you're here, and I’m far more interested in you.” His words bite at the air, and carry an amused certainty.
“Nice, nice.” I’m dismissive, uninterested, and yet he can’t get a clue.
Before I can get another word, he pushes on.
"Where were we? Oh, yes. Your life."
He gives me a sort of knowing smile. He’s certainly full of himself.
"I can give you things ordinary people have spent their entire lives chasing."
Yeah, no. That’s my cue for my exit. Now.
I barely make it a step before he moves in front of me, killing my momentum, blocking my path.
I stop and glare at the audacity of this man.
Of course. Of course, there was no easy escape from this disaster disguised as a pleasant conversation he pretends we’re having. Why would it ever be easy?
"Money. Fame. Power. Wealth. Immortality. Revenge. Love. Beauty. Really, darling, it's whatever your heart desires." His voice presented as kind, despite there being a touch of offended sarcasm that runs beneath it.
I struggle to suppress a laugh at his game.
Oh, wait…he's serious.
He extends a hand.
I stare and don't take it. I have a preference to not shake hands with a stranger’s delusions if it can be helped.
After a moment, he withdraws it, and clears his throat. It’s like he’s determined to continue his excessive salesmanship pitch; regardless of my lack of participation. Like he has personally taken this as a challenge he’s accepted to prove a point.
"My name is Satan. Lucifer, if you'd prefer. Though, if you're looking for something a little more formal, Lord of Lies, Prince of Darkness, King of Hell."
He smiles. Well, he’s clearly pleased with himself.
"I'm also something of a consultant of sorts, specializing in rectifying human dissatisfaction. And, my dear, you seem exquisitely dissatisfied."
"I'm really not interested in listening to any more of this…whatever weird proposal of a good time you’re trying to convince me of."
I move.
He moves with me.
Then I try again.
He follows my steps in an awkward dance, until I stop trying to evade him.
Oh, for God's sake. This is starting to feel less like a sales pitch and more like a predator begging its prey to participate in a game.
With a wave of his hand, a brown leather folder appears out of the air. His smile turns triumphant, even if it's wasted on an audience of one.
He opens it, revealing a contract covered in elegant handwriting. The black ink is beautifully precise, and the fine print is thick enough to make a lawyer cry.
"Now that I finally have your undivided attention, I'd love to present my offer."
He opens the folder a little wider in a slow reveal.
"Seven wishes in exchange for your immortal soul. It’s simple, really. You tell me what you want, I make it happen, and you get the deal of a lifetime."
He pauses, as if allowing his words to sink in.
"Once all seven wishes have been used, eventually, as they all must do, we settle our little arrangement.. Nothing complicated."
This insufferable idiot has now become a performer who refuses to leave the stage. Even then, I swear it almost looks like he wants to release a small sigh of relief at being able to get to the start of his offer. Perhaps I’ve delayed his usual flow, if so….good.
Then he places the contract on a table that hadn't existed a moment ago.
For some reason, I'm not surprised. Despite this…I get the feeling he's waiting for some kind of reaction. Perhaps he's hoping I'll be desperate, frightened, greedy, or at the very least impressed by his little tricks.
Unfortunately for him, I'm not particularly cooperative when I’m not in the mood, and most certainly when being forced to listen to unsolicited offers.
"Naturally, I'd insist you read the terms. I'm always a professional at heart. It's unfortunate you seem to be in such a hurry, darling."
Does this man ever shut up? Whatever scripts he follows it’s so practiced by a professional that it can be mistaken as genuine.
He steps closer.
Can I not just go home? He’s officially exhausted any reserves I had to be outside of the house. This is a waste of my last brain cell I’ve been sharing with the room. I’m at the point of posting ‘missing’ flyers.
“I couldn’t let you leave without introducing myself and, as you say, peddle my wares.” He smiles.
I glance over the page. No need to look at him anymore. It’s just going to piss me off more since I’m stuck here.
"Despite having such limited time with your attention, I wouldn't dream of rushing you through this part of the process. Not when it comes to a life-changing decision."
His innocent expression is almost convincing. But we both know better.
I give very little in response to his expectant silence that cries for my curiosity. He's holding onto the punchline of a joke I haven't agreed to hear, and he can keep it to himself....no, actually, he can choke on it.
Taking the silence as an invitation, the pitch continues, "Instead, I encourage you to consider the possibilities. Imagine finally having everything you've ever been denied."
He leans closer, clearly amused. I wonder how much joy he gets out of chasing someone who has no intention of being caught. It honestly can’t be that much. Not when he is presenting an arrogance that suggests such a theory.
"I should warn you, Diana. Wishes are rather delicate things."
His smile widens.
"Every word, intention, and detail matters. So I need you to consider what you say very carefully. I'd hate for there to be any misunderstandings."
That's possibly the most helpful lie I've ever heard.
"So, Diana, shall we make a deal? Tell me what you want most in this world. Anything you desire. Let's see if we can make your dreams come true."
Unfortunately for him, I'm not arrogant enough, like him, to believe I can beat the Devil at his own games. Nor am I desperate enough to believe salvation exists in his promises.
But he could have his uses. Even if six wishes are more than what I need. I just need one.
I know the stories. Lucifer doesn't have to deny a wish to ruin it. He’ll grant it exactly as you requested, technically fulfilling every word while delivering a devastating outcome. That's the game, and the truth. He’ll make it happen according to his interpretation, not mine.
I sigh.
"Pen, please."
My dismissive tone earns me an extra moment, barely a beat, before he places it in my hand.
"Well... impatience seems to be your enemy, darling. But I do love it when someone knows what they want."
He sounds pleased with himself, as if his sales pitch actually mattered.
It’s hard not to miss the little jab about ‘impatience.’ His attempt to regain some control of the interaction is interesting, considering I’m not giving him much to work with.
Pen to paper.
No hesitation.
My hand moves, and my name is signed.
I glance over at the Devil.
His smile falters, just slightly. There's a flicker of disappointment, as though he'd been looking forward to a game that never got played in the way he expected. Even if the destination remains the same.
My soul will... does belong to him.
Well, no reason to waste any time, and I speak my first desire: “I wish my ex would let my sister go and be at peace...” The moment the wish leaves my lips, the world tilts. The contract materializes a rush of changes upon the paper, ink still wet on the parchment, letters rearrange themselves before settling.
“Oh, how splendid, darling. There's nothing like an eager soul. I do love your passion.”
He snaps his fingers, and everything dissolves.
The next moment, we're standing in the middle of a park. Lush greenery stretches beneath a sunny, clear blue sky. The place is familiar, despite the subtle changes since I’ve visited. Why return to any damn place that’s filled with memories of him? This space is a metaphorical grave site.
And there they are.
James sits on a faded wooden bench, laughing with a woman who looks startlingly like Celia. It is her. It's a scene I've replayed in my mind over a hundred times, except this time they're no longer sneaking around or hiding. James is much older, the age gap painfully obvious. He's playing the part of a doting father figure, while she sits beside him, and she doesn’t realize she’s trapped in the lie of it all.
God, my stomach feels sick.
Lucifer lingers behind me. His warm presence presses against my back, an intoxicating weight. He leans closer, his voice a silken whisper against my ear. Expensive cologne and something sharp, almost like ozone, follow him and begin to envelop me.
“Behold,” he purrs, tone dripping with theatrical satisfaction. “The first wish, granted with such talented surgical precision. Now I believe your exact words were: ‘I wish my ex would let my sister go and be at peace.’”
The scene continues before me.
James shifts his weight on the park bench. He isn't clinging to Celia. He isn't manipulating her with his traps of false affection. He stands, and looks down at her with a bored expression.
She reaches out. Then he recoils, as if he's only just noticed the proximity of her presence.
“Actually, Celia,” he says, his voice stripped bare of the sweetness that used to make my blood boil, “I think…no, I know I'm done. With everything.”
He takes a step away, creating space.
“I can't even remember why I wanted you around after Diana and I broke up. I think I just felt bad for you. You're a good kid, but this isn't going to work.”
How rich. Always one to minimize his intentions for a grown woman.
Celia looks up at him. Confusion crosses her face before giving way to something much worse as he says, “I can't replace your father.”
Silence.
“What are you talking about? We were just…but…” her words break through.
“I don't know.” He interrupts her, already retreating farther away. “I just…”
His voice trails off. Never pausing his movement. He doesn't offer an explanation. He doesn't look back.
Celia remains on the bench, staring after him, her breathing becoming shallow.
The park goes quiet. No birdsong. No rustling leaves. Nothing. Just Celia sitting alone with the sudden loss of the father figure she'd believed she had for the last several years.
But I know the truth of the lie he'd built around her. And now it’s been destroyed. Years of her being trapped as an unwitting pawn in all his bullshit.
Lucifer's hand settles on my shoulder. His touch is light, yet burns with restrained victory.
“Oh, did I misunderstand you, darling? You did say you wished he would let your sister go and be at peace. And look!”
He gives a grand gesture toward James's retreating figure.
Lucifer draws my attention back to Celia.
“She’s gone. As gone as anyone can be when their father abandons them with all the tenderness of a man disposing of yesterday's garbage. I'd say he went out to purchase cigarettes and milk, but it'd be far more clichéd.”
I barely listen to his rambling. His words are of no consequence. Not that they were before.
It hits me, and my chest tightens.
It's over.
It's all over.
Relief blooms in my chest.
My eyes water as my hands cover my mouth.
God, I can't hold it in.
Fuck.
And the tears fall.
Lucifer's hand tightens on my shoulder, offering what I assume is meant to be a comforting formality. Then he goes rigid as I turn and throw my arms around him.
I clasp him to my chest and lock him in an embrace.
He'd done the one thing I couldn't. Not because I didn’t want to, but because I didn’t have the ability to do so. Not for what was needed to produce the best possible outcome.
“Thank you.”
My words shake with gratitude. I don’t even bother to control it. Not for this point in time.
That wasn't what he expected. Not at all.
Sure, gratitude was one thing, even a satisfied client wouldn’t have been unexpected. But it was the way she threw her arms around him…It was as if he’d given her something precious beyond superficial desire.
For a moment, he stood there, before Lucifer's arms closed around me, drawing my body against his. He doesn't move away. Then a soft chuckle vibrates through his chest. His hands begin rubbing small circles against my back.
“There, there, darling,” he murmurs, his voice deep and soothing. “This’s exactly what I'm here for. I do love it when a wish leaves a client satisfied. In fact, I find tears to be a testament to my skill.”
He pauses.
“The only thing sweeter than watching a wish come true is witnessing someone appreciate what goes into making it happen. It's truly a joy.”
His thumbs trace lazy patterns over my shoulders. With my face buried into his suit, I turn my head to draw a clear, shaky breath.
“I don't think it could've been done better,” I confess. “I couldn't have…”
The words catch. I can't quite finish the thought. I close my eyes, and deny any further indulgences to the relief. It’s all I can afford.
With another deep breath and a slow exhale, I manage to gather what remains of my composure.
“Anyway…I need to go.”
There are too many affairs to settle. Last minute experiences to have. All those little things people take for granted until they realize there's time left.
Lucifer doesn't release me immediately. His grip remains firm but gentle, as though he's reluctant to end the unguarded hug. His cheek rests against the side of my head. I feel him breathe in.
When I finally pull away, there's a small, predatory smile on his face.
“Going so soon?” he asks, his voice a low, melodic rumble. “We've only just begun our little dance, Diana.”
When I finally speak, and my words come out carefully, they’re almost even breathless.
“I would like a moment of peace,” my voice remains steady. “I don't think you understand the situation. I just…give me a day, and I'll make another wish. I know what you want, and I'll make it easy.”
His eyes remain fixed on mine, their intensity almost tangible.
I hesitate.
“I just…It was worth it.”
Lucifer's lips curl into a knowing smile. His gaze doesn't leave mine. He watches me for a moment, taking in every nuance of what I've said.
His arms remain around me a beat longer than necessary, as if he's savoring the last of my warmth.
“You, darling,” he murmurs, his voice silken smooth, "know how to make an offer I can't refuse."
His fingers trail lightly up and down my back, a gentle, teasing gesture
Oh, how adorable. Thinks he can make a pass at me. Lull me into a false sense of security.
Whatever. If it gets me away faster and saves me the trouble of dealing with one more minute of his grand performance, great.
“Very well,” he concedes, tilting his head as though granting me some rare indulgence. “A day of peace.”
***********
Finally, I'm home.
The loneliness of the house doesn't help, though for once, I'm grateful for it. It’s a blessing for the occasion.
There are things to do, but the gravity of the situation pulls at me, the weight of everything presses down. I need to let some of it out and expel it from my body. I can't afford to carry all of this around to distract from my focus.
I set an alarm, crawl into bed, and cry. I need to let out as much as I can. Every last bit that’s allowed.
She's safe now. She'll never know it, but Celia is no longer at risk of going through the same thing. While there wasn’t any guarantee he'd leave her alone, or try anything. done anything. But, now I know he won't be a threat to her anymore…and that’s all that matters.
It wouldn’t have even been an issue, if I hadn’t been so stupid in my youth. One decision led to so much suffering.
Eventually, the wave begins to recede. Enough for me to get started. I sniffle and wipe my face.
I need a distraction.
Let's see…what would be productive…well, how will I use my remaining six wishes?
I sit up, straighten myself out, and place my feet on the floor.
He’s going to mess them up. That’s an inevitable fact. At least the most important wish, the one that mattered most, was granted as it should've been.
More thoughts start to creep into my mind. I shove them away. Refusing to spend the last hours wallowing over my ex.
Then the air shifts.
Lucifer appears in the doorway, his form materializing from the shadows. He wears a suit that fits him far too well, the fabric shifting in the dim light as he moves forward with a grace that defies the space around the room.
Wow. Can't even get a whole ass day.
“Darling,” he purrs, leaning against the doorframe with casual confidence. “Your peace has lasted exactly thirty-seven minutes. I'm afraid I couldn't resist checking in. I needed to see if you were still experiencing the desired effects of your first wish.”
His eyes settle on my tear-streaked face. The amusement in his expression gives way to something harder to read.
The clothes barely make as sound as he produces a silver flask from his jacket, offering it with another damn theatrical flourish.
“Drink this, darling.”
I shake my head and wipe my face. My voice comes out unsteady, yet suggests no weakness.
“So eager to claim a soul. If you want, I can rattle them all off right now. Every last wish. They're going to be meaningless anyway.”
Lucifer stops mid-stride.
His eyebrows rise in genuine surprise. He doesn't look offended. If anything, he looks delighted.
A low, melodic laugh escapes him, reverberating the very walls of my bedroom, as he sets the flask on the nightstand with a slow, deliberate motion. He moves forward, not with the predatory hunger of a demon, nor even eager to play the predator. In its place is the poised curiosity of a collector who has just found a spirited specimen unexpectedly interesting.
He sits on the edge of the mattress, making it dip beneath his weight. Lucifer leans closer than necessary. Too damn close. The scent of ozone and expensive sandalwood cloud my senses.
"Meaningless?" he repeats, his voice almost coming out as a seductive velvet purr, like a signal for Act II of the play production.
“Yes, you’ll mess them up. Every single one of them will be perfect enough to hope, yet flawed enough for me to beg for the next. I have no interest in suffering through those games. I've reached my limit.”
I look at him.
You did the one thing I wanted, the one thing I knew you'd fuck up. And somehow, you perfectly completed it the way it needed to be done. Not just partly. Exactly."
Lucifer stills.
For once, the theatrical expression doesn't immediately return. Something shifts behind his eyes. Irritation? Admiration? I can't quite tell.
He studies my face, letting the silence grow heavier, as the air is charged with a sudden, electric tension.
I know the game. I know what he is. I'm not sitting here hoping I'll be the exception to the rules. I don’t need to see behind his curtain of tricks and assess the gears turning to understand that much.
His hand rises, brushing a stray lock of hair away from my forehead. The gesture is almost tender.
“My, my,” he whispers. “A woman who knows exactly how the game is played. You're not just a therapist, Diana. You're a strategist.”
********Author's Notes:*********
I don't usually write dark romances, but I felt inspired by the show 'The Great' (the only sort of dark romance I've been okay with....for some reason) with Nicholas Hoult and Elle Fanning. This is not a fan-fic. But I'm glad I at least found the max amount of toxic I can handle. As messed up as it was I liked how Catherine never looses her identity and Peter becomes more than the man who Catherine wants. Anyway, the text I put here, most of the time....italics are a snippets of Lucifer's perception of his own experience. Just to let you know case there is a WTF moment. I am trying to see if this method will work...instead of using a ton of page breaks as well as having one chapter POV each. I have the switching POV's with my other manuscripts I have sitting around...collecting dust. For this, I didn't want to give Lucifer a full POV, just little snippets of his perspective. I'll need to see whether I have to make any adjustments as the story progresses (finger's crossed that it works). Just trying something new!
Anyway....thank you for reading!